Skip to Main content
* Not Affiliated with the New York City Police Department
  • 1 NYPD Pizza Lake Cay

Currently not accepting online orders

NYPD Pizza Lake Cay 9900 Universal Blvd

9900 Universal Blvd, orlando, FL
Appetizer
Pizza By The Slice
Classic New York Pies
Specialty Pizzas
Gluten Free Pizza
The Witness Protection Program
Fresh Salads
Calzones & Specialty Rolls
Gourmet Heroes
Pasta & Specialty Dishes
Desserts
Kids Menu
Beverages
Sides

Featured Items

  • Mozzarella Sticks

    Served with a side of our Homemade Marinara Sauce
    $9.00
  • Flight Mini Cheesecakes

    Locally Sourced with Cheesecake Chino's. Our Artisan Treats, Quality Handcrafted Cheesecakes.
  • Garlic Knots

    Freshly Baked Knots with Garlic Butter and Herbs.
    $1.50+

Appetizer

  • Chicken Wings (Boneless)

    Breaded White Breast Meat Chunks
    $13.00
  • Chicken Wings (Naked)

    Naked Fried Wing
    $9.00
  • Fried Pickles

    Served with a side of Spicy Ranch Dressing
    $7.00
  • Fried Raviolis

    Raviolis Lightly Fried and Served with Our Homemade Marinara Sauce
    $9.00
  • Garlic Knots

    Freshly Baked Knots with Garlic Butter and Herbs.
    $1.50+
  • House Soup

    $5.00
  • Jones Beach Fries

    $6.00
  • Mom's Meatballs

    Made with Mom's Special Ingredients
    $7.00
  • Mozzarella Sticks

    Served with a side of our Homemade Marinara Sauce
    $9.00

Pizza By The Slice

  • Cheese Slice

    $3.50
  • Oneonta Cheese Slice

    Cheese Slice with Cold Shredded Mozzarella Cheese after cook
    $4.00

Classic New York Pies

  • Famous Cheese Pie

    Shredded Mozzarella, Pizza Sauce with Italian Herbs and Spices.
    $10.00+
  • Bayside Bianca

    Herb Ricotta Cheese, Minced Garlic, Mozzarella Cheese and Italian Herbs.
    $12.00+
  • Grandma Pie

    A rectangular homemade style pie, garlic infused olive oil, mozzarella, thick stripes of sauce and fresh basil.
    $21.00
  • The Sicilian Pie

    Thick Seasoned Crust, Mozzarella, Pizza Sauce with Italian Herbs and Spices
    $21.00

Specialty Pizzas

  • APB Alfredo Pie

    Alfredo Sauce, Italian Herbs, Minced Garlic and Mozzarella Cheese.
    $12.00+
  • Brooklyn Buffalo Chicken Pie

    Grilled Chicken, Medium Wing Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese, finished with a Blue Cheese Dressing drizzle after cook.
    $13.00+
  • Carnegie Hall Chicken Club Pie

    Bacon, Diced Tomatoes, Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese and finished with a Ranch Drizzle.
    $13.00+
  • Da' Bronx BBQ Chicken Pie

    Grilled Chicken, Red Onions and Mozzarella Cheese with BBQ and Pizza Sauce.
    $13.00+
  • Hawaiian Pie

    Ham, Pineapple and Mozzarella Cheese.
    $12.00+
  • Killer Bee Pie

    Char & Cup Pepperoni, Mozzarella Cheese and Pizza Sauce, finished with Mike's Hot Honey after cook.
    $13.00+
  • Manhattan Meat Lovers Pie

    Pepperoni, Meatballs, Bacon and Mozzarella Cheese.
    $13.00+
  • Margherita Pie

    Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Roma Tomatoes, Pizza Sauce, Fresh Basil, Minced Garlic and Olive Oil
    $12.00+
  • Mariano Pie

    Olive Oil, Diced Tomatoes, Garlic, Basil and Mozzarella
    $12.00+
  • Queens Deluxe Pie

    Pepperoni, Sausage, Onion, Mushroom, Green Pepper and Mozzarella Cheese.
    $13.00+
  • Rosalie's Vegetarian Pie

    Onions, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Tomato and Mozzarella Cheese.
    $13.00+
  • Salsiccia Pie

    Italian Sausage, Fresh Mozzarella, Caramelized Onions, Roasted Garlic, Parmesan Cheese and a hint of Red Pepper.
    $13.00+
  • Staten Island Stuffed Pie 18"

    A Double Layer of Dough Stuffed with your choice of Two Standard Toppings and Mozzarella Cheese, served with a side of Marinara Sauce. Premium toppings available for an additional charge.
    $26.00

Gluten Free Pizza

  • 10" Gluten Free Pizza

    Choose any of our 10" pizzas with a Gluten Free Crust. Select Famous Cheese or one of our Specialty Pies, then customize with your favorite toppings. Please note: Although prepared using a gluten-free crust, our kitchen is a flour-rich environment and cross-contact may occur.
    $10.00

The Witness Protection Program

  • Wickle Pickle Pie

    Sweet & Spicy Wickles Pickles, Bacon, Mozzarella Cheese, Alfredo Sauce finished with a drizzle of Ranch Dressing.
    $14.00
  • WOW Factor Pie

    Loaded with Double Pepperoni! Classic and Char & Cupped Pepperoni.
    $13.00
  • Quattro Formaggi Pie

    Mozzarella Cheese, Asiago, Ricotta, Grated Parmesan, topped with Minced Garlic and Fresh Basil.
    $14.00
  • Chelsea Market Sweet Heat Pie

    Bianca Pie with Sausage, Caramelized Onion and finished with Mike's Hot Honey.
    $14.00

Fresh Salads

  • Astoria Greek Salad

    Romaine Lettuce, Kalamata Olives, Pepperoncinis, Onion, Tomato, Roasted Red Peppers and Feta Cheese
    $7.00
  • Broadway Blue Cheese Salad

    Romaine Lettuce, Blue Cheese Crumbles, Diced Tomato, Onion and Cinnamon Roasted Pecans
    $7.00
  • Caesar Salad

    Romaine Lettuce, Shredded Parmesan Cheese and Croutons
    $6.00
  • Columbus Circle Caprese Salad

    Fresh Mozzarella, Sliced Tomato, Basil drizzled with Extra Virgin Olive Oil and Balsamic Fig Glaze
    $13.00
  • House Salad

    Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Onion and Croutons
    $6.00
  • Little Italy Antipasta Salad

    Iceberg Lettuce with Salami, Ham, Pepperoni and Cheese Pinwheels, Tomato, Black & Green Olives, Onions and Pepperoncinis
    $15.00
  • Soho Cobb Salad

    Iceberg Lettuce, Grilled Chicken, Smoked Bacon, Hard Boiled Egg, Tomato, Onion and Blue Cheese Crumbles
    $15.00

Calzones & Specialty Rolls

  • Swat Team Stromboli

    Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Mozzarella
    $14.00
  • Patrolman's Pepperoni Roll

    Triple Pepperoni with Double Mozzarella
    $13.00
  • Make Your Own Roll

    Add any Pizza Toppings to make your favorite variety.
    $12.00
  • Convict Cheese Calzone

    Mozzarella & Herb Ricotta Cheese Mix
    $14.00

Gourmet Heroes

  • Chicken Parmigiana Hero

    Breaded Chicken Breast, Mozzarella Cheese, Marinara served on a 10" Semolina Roll
    $14.00
  • Eggplant Parmigiana Hero

    Naples Style Eggplant, Mozzarella Cheese, Marinara Cheese served on a 10" Semolina Roll
    $12.00
  • Italian Combo Hero

    Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone Cheese, Shredded Lettuce, Tomato, side of House Italian Dressing served on a 10" Semolina Roll
    $11.00
  • Meatball Parmigiana Hero

    Meatballs, Mozzarella Cheese, Marinara Sauce served on a 10" Semolina Roll
    $12.00
  • Penn Station Cheese Steak

    Thinly Sliced Steak, Onions, Green Peppers, Melted American Cheese served on a 10" Roll
    $14.00

Pasta & Specialty Dishes

  • Baked Ziti

    Riccotta & Mozzarella, Baked Well Done
    $15.00
  • Chicken Parmigiana

    Chicken Breasts, Marinara, Mozzarella with choice of Pasta
    $20.00
  • Eggplant Parmigiana

    Naples Style Eggplant, Marinara, Mozzarella with choice of Pasta
    $15.00
  • Fettuccine Alfredo

    Made withg Heavy Cream and a blend of Italian Cheeses
    $15.00
  • Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken

    Fettuccine Alfredo with Grilled Chicken
    $19.00
  • Homemade Lasagna

    Layers of Pasta, Sausage, Meatball, Marinara, Riccotta & Mozzarella
    $17.00
  • Pasta Bolognese

    Our Homemade Meat Sauce with Pasta Choice
    $17.00
  • Pasta Marinara

    Homemade Marinara Sauce, with choice of pasta
    $12.00
  • Pasta Marinara with Meatballs

    Pasta Marinara with 2 Meatballs
    $15.00

Desserts

  • Zeppoles

    Our Special Dough Fried, Covered in Powdered or Cinnamon Sugar
    $6.00
  • Mini New York Cannoli

    A Two Bite Pastry Shell filled with Sweet Ricotta Cream, Dusted with Powdered Sugar
    $2.50
  • Large New York Cannoli

    Pastry Shell filled with Sweet Ricotta Cream, Dusted with Powdered Sugar. Big enough to share or not!
    $7.00
  • Chocolate Large New York Cannoli

    Chocolate Dipped Pastry Shell filled with Sweet Ricotta Cream, Dusted with Powdered Sugar
    $8.00
  • Mini Cheesecakes

    Locally Sourced with Cheesecake Chino's. Our Artisan Treats, Quality Handcrafted Cheesecakes.
  • Flight Mini Cheesecakes

    Locally Sourced with Cheesecake Chino's. Our Artisan Treats, Quality Handcrafted Cheesecakes.
  • Slice of Cheesecake

    Locally Sourced with Cheesecake Chino's. Our Artisan Treats, Quality Handcrafted Cheesecakes.
  • Whole Cheesecakes

    Locally Sourced with Cheesecake Chino's. Our Artisan Treats, Quality Handcrafted Cheesecakes.
  • Chocolate Triple Layer Cake

    Dark Chocolate Cake layered high, filled with Rich Chocolate Cream Filling
    $8.00
  • Black & White Cookies

    $3.00

Kids Menu

  • Kid's Classic Cheese Slice

    $7.00
  • Sergeant's Spaghetti

    $7.00
  • Metropolis Meatballs

    $8.00
  • Zoo Crew Chicken Bites

    $8.00
  • Kids Mandarin Oranges

    $1.50
  • Kids Fountain Soda

    $2.00
  • Kids Milk

    $2.00
  • Kids Apple Juice

    $2.00
  • Kids Orange Juice

    $2.00
  • Kids Tea

    $2.00

Beverages

  • Fountain Drinks

    $3.50
  • Gatorade - Bottle

    $3.50
  • Pepsi Sodas - Bottle

    $3.50
  • Pepsi Soda - 2 Liter

    $4.50
  • Fresh Brewed Tea

    $3.50
  • Hot Coffee

    $2.50
  • Hot Tea

    $2.50
  • Bottled Water

    $2.50
  • Bottle Perrier Water

    $3.00
  • Large Milk

    $3.00
  • Large Apple Juice

    $3.00
  • Large Orange Juice

    $3.00
  • Water

Sides

  • Side Marinara Sauce

    $0.60
  • Side Pizza Sauce

    $0.80
  • Side Dressing

    $0.50
  • Side Large Dressing (8oz)

    $2.00
  • Side Wing Sauce

    $0.50
  • Side Garlic Butter

    $1.00
  • Side Alfredo Sauce

    $2.00
  • Side Ricotta Cheese

    $2.00
  • Side Hot Honey

    $2.00
  • Side Bolognese Sauce

    $3.00
  • Side Pesto Sauce

    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.00
  • Side Veggies

    $0.50
  • Side Anchovies

    $1.50
  • Side Fig Glaze

    $2.50
  • Side Large Marinara (8oz)

    $1.60

Mom's Meatballs

$7.00

Made with Mom's Special Ingredients

1

1 NYPD Pizza Lake Cay Location and Hours

(407) 992-8990
9900 Universal Blvd, orlando, FL 32819
Closed • Opens Saturday at 11AM
View menu
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement